A thought leadership piece contributed by Disputes Partner, Adrian Lyon, for the Newark Advertiser, discussing a particularly unusual scenario encountered in the courtroom.
When inheritance promises are broken
A regular theme in farming disputes is promises made in succession planning. The law has developed to deal with situations where people have made and received promises, but those promises have been broken. The classic situation in farming families might be where a farmer looks out over the fields and says to his child ‘one day, all this will be yours’. The child then works on the farm for many years, often for little income, giving up far more lucrative work in the expectation of future reward by way of inheritance. However, when the parent dies it transpires that they have given the farm to somebody else. The child is understandably aggrieved by this, turns to lawyers and dispute arises.
What the courts look for
The courts look for four things. First, a clear and unambiguous promise made by one person to another. Second, reliance on that promise by the recipient. Third, detriment suffered as a result of that reliance. Fourth, that it would be unconscionable for the promisor to resile from their promise. Those issues have given rise to many court claims over the years; for example, one side argues that a clear promise was made, whereas the other asserts that it was just a general expression in passing of future possibility.
The full article is here.
INSIGHTS DISCLAIMER
Please be advised that this is an update which we think may be of general interest to our wider client base. The insights are not intended to be exhaustive or targeted at specific sectors as such, and whilst we naturally take every care in putting our articles together, they should not be considered a substitute for obtaining proper legal advice on key issues which your business may face.
Share